"MALCOLM COLEMAN was probably born
near Carlisle, Pa. (Lancaster County - now Cumberland
County, PA) in 1740. There is a possibility he was born in
Scotland and immigrated with his parents as a child. In 1763
he was living near the Susquehanna River when the Indians
killed his young brother. In 1773-1778 he was listed in the
Bedford Co. Militia.
In April 1787, Michael Coleman and
family and son John and family from near Carlisle Pa.
arrived at Fort Belleville (W)VA. It is recorded that he
(MICHAEL) had performed garrison duty at Fort Pitt, Fort
Harmer (Marietta), Fort Henry (Wheeling) and Fort Belleville
(Virginia - present day Wood County, WV). They arrived with
four other Scotch families.
In February 1793. "A party composed
of Malcolm Coleman and his son John, James Ryan and Elijah
Rixley, left the garrison at Belleville for the purpose of
getting a supply of meat. They descended the Ohio in a
pioroque to the mouth of Big Mill Creek, then proceeded up
that stream and encamped near the site of Cottageville. In a
few days their boat was loaded with a supply of venison and
bear meat.
Meanwhile the creek had frozen over
and they were not able to reach the Ohio. Thus detained,
John Coleman and Elijah Rixley returned overland to the
garrison for a supply of flour and salt. They were expected
to return from the garrison on the morning of the third, and
Malcolm and James prepared an early breakfast. While Malcolm
was invoking the Divine blessing, the Indians in ambush
poured a shower of balls upon them, and Coleman fell dead.
Ryan, but slightly wounded, made his
escape and conveyed his sad intelligence to Belleville. A
party set out at once for the camp, and arriving there
found, it plundered and the body of Coleman scalped and
stripped of its clothing. The body was buried on the spot
and the party returned to the garrison. From that time John
Coleman became noted as an Indian hunter, never losing an
opportunity to run down and kill every Indian that crossed
his path in revenge for this wanton murder".
In the town of Cottageville, there is
a marker off the highway situated in a little road side rest
area that reads: "Michael Coleman, member of a hunting party
from frontier fort at Belleville, was killed and scalped by
Indians at this point about 1793..."